CREAMED SPINACH WITH FETA CHEESE (2 EASY STYLES, NEVER WATERY)

Creamed Spinach with Feta Cheese used to feel like one of those moody recipes to me — the kind that behaves perfectly in restaurants but turns watery and weird the second you try making creamed spinach with feta cheese at home. The first time I cooked it, I was feeling very confident… until my pan looked like spinach soup and the feta decided to clump together like it was personally offended. I stood there, spoon in hand, staring at it like, who hurt you?

But here’s the thing — I’m stubborn in the kitchen, and I really love figuring out why recipes misbehave. So I kept testing this creamed spinach with feta cheese again and again. Fresh spinach, frozen spinach, different fetas, different creams. I squeezed spinach like it owed me money. I learned exactly when to add feta (spoiler: she absolutely hates boiling).

And now? This creamed spinach with feta cheese is one of my favorite side dishes. Cozy, creamy, bold, and totally reliable. The kind of recipe that makes you feel calm instead of stressed — which, honestly, is how cooking should always feel. 💚

Table of Contents

Table of Contents

Creamed Spinach with Feta Cheese: Choose Your Style

This creamed spinach with feta cheese comes in two easy styles, depending on what you’re cooking and how rich you want it. I make this side dish often, especially with cozy dinners like crockpot steak and potatoes or lighter meals like citrusy salmon packets—and both versions work beautifully.

Steakhouse-Creamy Version

Rich, thick, and ultra-comforting. The feta is added at the end so it melts smoothly without turning grainy.

Best for: steak, chicken, holidays, or serving as a dip.

Mediterranean-Light Version

Creamy but lighter, with a touch of lemon and Greek-inspired flavor. Fresh and not heavy.

Best for: salmon, lamb, vegetables, or Mediterranean-style dinners.

Quick Comparison

You want…	Choose
Thick, rich, restaurant-style	Steakhouse-Creamy
Light but still creamy	Mediterranean-Light
A scoopable dip	Steakhouse-Creamy
A fresh side for fish	Mediterranean-Light

Flavor at a Glance

Both versions of creamed spinach with feta cheese are:

• Creamy
• Garlicky
• Tangy from feta
• Easy to customize with herbs or chili flakes

Print

Ingredients That Matter (And Why They Matter)

With creamed spinach with feta cheese, the ingredients are simple — but how you choose them makes all the difference between creamy and disappointing. This is one of those recipes where a few smart decisions save you from watery sauce, bland flavor, or overpowering salt.

Spinach: Fresh vs Frozen (Both Work)

You can use either, but they behave differently.

Fresh spinach

• Brighter flavor
• Softer texture
• Needs wilting and moisture control

Frozen spinach

• More convenient
• Slightly stronger spinach taste
• Requires thorough squeezing (this step is non-negotiable)

👉 If you already cook with creamy greens or cheese-heavy dishes, this choice matters just as much as it does in recipes like a rich cheese-based sauce or vegetable purée.

Feta Cheese (This One Choice Can Make or Break It)

Not all feta tastes the same, and in creamed spinach with feta cheese, salt balance is everything.

Best feta options

• Block feta (crumble it yourself) → creamier, less dry
• Sheep or sheep-goat feta → tangier, more complex
• Cow’s milk feta → milder, less sharp

Avoid if possible

• Pre-crumbled feta (drier, saltier, doesn’t melt as well)

💡 Tip: Always taste your feta before adding any salt to the dish.

Choosing Your Creamy Base

This is where the two versions start to separate.

For the Steakhouse-Creamy version

• Cream cheese (most stable, very forgiving)
• Heavy cream or half-and-half
• Optional parmesan for depth

For the Mediterranean-Light version

• Ricotta or Greek yogurt
• Olive oil instead of butter
• Lemon for brightness

Both approaches work beautifully in creamed spinach with feta cheese — you’re just choosing richness vs lightness.

Flavor Builders That Do the Heavy Lifting

You don’t need much, but these small additions make the dish taste “finished”:

• Garlic – savory base without overpowering
• Nutmeg – classic with creamy spinach (just a pinch)
• Lemon – balances richness and feta saltiness
• Chili flakes or herbs – optional, but great for personality

Moisture Control: How to Prevent Watery Creamed Spinach

Watery sauce is the fastest way to ruin creamed spinach with feta cheese. Spinach releases a lot of liquid when heated, and if that water goes into the sauce, it turns thin and soupy. Moisture control always comes first.

Fresh Spinach: Quick Prep

• Wilt just until collapsed
• Press out excess liquid with a spoon or towel
• Spinach should feel damp, not wet, with no dripping liquid

If it still looks shiny, press again.

Frozen Spinach: The Squeeze Test

Frozen spinach works great, but only if you squeeze it well.

• Thaw completely
• Squeeze small handfuls firmly
• Stop only when no liquid comes out

If it drips, it’s not ready.

If Your Sauce Looks Too Thin

• Simmer gently for a few minutes to reduce liquid
• Add a little more cream cheese or ricotta
• Wait to add feta until the sauce thickens

Once the sauce coats the spoon, you’re good to continue.

Version 1: Steakhouse-Creamy Creamed Spinach with Feta

This is the rich, classic version of creamed spinach with feta cheese — thick, spoonable, and exactly what you want next to steak or chicken. The key here is building a stable creamy base first, then finishing with feta off the heat so it melts smoothly.

Ingredients (Steakhouse Version)

• Spinach (fresh or frozen, prepped properly)
• Butter or olive oil
• Garlic
• Cream cheese (for stability)
• Heavy cream or half-and-half
• Feta cheese (crumbled)
• Salt & black pepper
• Pinch of nutmeg (optional)

Step-by-Step Method (Short & Clear)

1. Sauté garlic gently in butter or oil until fragrant (not browned).
2. Add cream cheese + cream, stirring until smooth and creamy.
3. Stir in spinach, making sure the sauce stays thick.
4. Remove from heat, then add feta and stir gently until just melted.

The sauce should be thick enough to coat a spoon before the feta goes in.

When to Add Feta (Important)

Feta should never boil. High heat makes it grainy and overly salty.

Rule of thumb:

• Heat off or very low
• Stir gently
• Stop as soon as it melts into the sauce

Taste Ladder (Quick Fixes Before Serving)

If something feels off, here’s how to fix it fast:

• Too bland → pinch of salt or parmesan
• Too salty → splash of cream or more spinach
• Too thick → small splash of milk
• Too thin → simmer briefly before adding feta

Version 2: Mediterranean-Light Creamed Spinach with Feta Cheese & Lemon

This Mediterranean-light creamed spinach with feta cheese is creamy without feeling heavy. It keeps the comfort of classic creamed spinach but adds brightness from lemon and a gentler dairy base, making this version perfect when you want something fresh and balanced.

If you love creamed spinach with feta cheese but sometimes find the steakhouse version too rich, this lighter approach is a game changer.

Ingredients (Mediterranean Version)

For this Mediterranean creamed spinach with feta cheese, you’ll need:

• Spinach (fresh or frozen, moisture-controlled)
• Olive oil
• Garlic
• Ricotta or Greek yogurt (lighter creamy base)
• Feta cheese, crumbled
• Lemon juice (freshly squeezed)
• Black pepper
• Optional: dill or oregano

This combination keeps the creamed spinach with feta cheese smooth, tangy, and fresh-tasting.

Step-by-Step Mediterranean Method

1. Warm olive oil and garlic gently until fragrant.
2. Add the creamy base (ricotta or Greek yogurt) and stir until smooth.
3. Fold in the spinach, keeping the heat low so the sauce stays creamy.
4. Remove from heat, then stir in feta cheese and lemon juice.

The result should be a soft, spoonable creamed spinach with feta cheese that tastes bright, not sharp.

Lemon + Feta Balance (Don’t Skip This)

With Mediterranean creamed spinach with feta cheese, balance is everything.

• Start with a small squeeze of lemon
• Taste before adding more
• Let the dish rest for 1–2 minutes, then adjust

Too much lemon can overpower the feta, while the right amount makes the creamed spinach with feta cheese taste fresh and vibrant.

Optional Mediterranean Add-Ins

These work beautifully with creamed spinach with feta cheese if you want extra personality:

• Fresh dill or oregano
• Toasted pine nuts
• Extra feta sprinkled on top before serving

Nutrition Information (What You’re Eating)

This creamed spinach with feta cheese is comfort food with real nutritional value. Spinach brings fiber and micronutrients, feta adds protein and flavor, and the overall profile depends on which version you choose.

Nutrition Snapshot (Approximate, Per Serving)

Nutrient	Steakhouse-Creamy	Mediterranean-Light
Calories	220–260 kcal	170–210 kcal
Protein	7–9 g	6–8 g
Fat	18–22 g	12–16 g
Carbohydrates	6–8 g	6–8 g
Fiber	2–3 g	2–3 g
Sugar	<2 g	<2 g

Values vary based on ingredients and portion size.

Is Creamed Spinach with Feta Cheese Healthy?

Yes — especially when it’s part of a balanced meal.

Why this dish works:

• Spinach is nutrient-dense and naturally low in calories
• Feta delivers bold flavor, so a small amount goes a long way
• The dish is low in sugar and naturally gluten-free

Spinach is widely recognized for its vitamin and mineral content, as shown in USDA spinach nutrition data, making it a smart base for creamy side dishes.

A Note on Feta & Salt

Feta cheese adds protein and richness, but it’s naturally higher in sodium. That’s why tasting before salting is important — especially in creamed spinach with feta cheese.

According to Harvard’s Nutrition Source on cheese, stronger cheeses tend to be more sodium-dense, which reinforces the “add salt last” rule in this recipe.

How to Adjust the Nutrition (If You Want To)

If you’re making creamed spinach with feta cheese often, here are easy ways to adapt it:

• Choose the Mediterranean-light version
• Use ricotta or Greek yogurt instead of heavy cream
• Increase spinach for more volume without many calories

You still get a creamy, satisfying side — just with a lighter everyday feel.

Dietary Notes

This creamed spinach with feta cheese fits many eating styles:

• Vegetarian: ✔
• Gluten-free: ✔
• Low-carb friendly: ✔
• Keto-friendly: ✔ (use full-fat dairy, no flour)

What to Serve with Creamed Spinach with Feta Cheese

This creamed spinach with feta cheese works as more than just a side dish — it’s versatile enough to pair with hearty mains, lighter proteins, or even turn into a dip-style addition to the table.

Best Protein Pairings

Creamy, garlicky spinach loves bold or simply cooked proteins. I especially like serving creamed spinach with feta cheese alongside:

• Beef and steak dishes
• Roasted or stuffed chicken
• Salmon or other flaky fish
• Lamb (especially Mediterranean-style)

It pairs beautifully with cozy dinners like crockpot steak and potatoes when you want something rich and comforting.

Carbs That Work Well

To soak up that creamy sauce, serve creamed spinach with feta cheese with:

• Pasta or baked ziti
• Rice or orzo
• Roasted or mashed potatoes
• Crusty bread or focaccia

For lighter meals, it’s also great next to fish dishes like citrusy salmon packets.

Quick Pairing Guide

Main Dish Type	Why It Works
Steak or beef	Rich spinach balances savory meat
Chicken	Creamy + mild = perfect match
Salmon or fish	Feta tang cuts through richness
Pasta	Sauce clings beautifully
Crusty bread	Ideal for scooping

Turn It Into a Dip or Appetizer

This creamed spinach with feta cheese can easily pull double duty:

• Make the steakhouse-creamy version extra thick
• Transfer to a baking dish
• Top with extra feta and bake until warm and bubbly

Serve with toasted bread, pita, or crackers for an easy appetizer that feels a little fancy but takes almost no extra effort.

Frequently Asked Questions About Creamed Spinach with Feta Cheese

Final Thoughts

If there’s one thing I hope you take away from this recipe, it’s that creamed spinach with feta cheese doesn’t need to be stressful. Once you understand moisture control and when to add the feta, everything else falls into place.

Whether you go for the steakhouse-creamy version on a cozy night or the Mediterranean-light version when you want something fresh and bright, this dish is meant to work in a real kitchen — not just look good in photos.

Taste as you go. Trust your instincts. And remember: if it’s creamy, garlicky, and makes you want a second spoonful straight from the pan, you did it right. 💚

Save it, print it, make it your own — and enjoy every bite of your creamed spinach with feta cheese.

for more recipes follow me in Facebook, Pinterest and medium.